Many legends are associated with Chaliapin's visit to Plyos. One of them tells how Chaliapin, upon entering a house where his recording was playing on a gramophone, continued to sing the aria, surprising those present with his appearance. Another story revolves around one of Chaliapin's departures from Uteshnoye. It is said that as he was leaving, “...he wanted to board a passing steamboat from a boat, but for some reason, the steamboat did not want to stop. Then Chaliapin sang one of his operatic arias, and the captain of the steamboat, hearing the famous singer's voice, immediately recognized him and stopped the steamboat. Chaliapin boarded it and went to his family in Moscow.”
Guides also tell how Chaliapin, after disembarking from the steamboat in Plyos, “...leisurely walked through the market square, bought five pounds of sunflower seeds, and, shelling them, looked around with a smile. 'Chaliapin!' was heard in the gathering crowd. 'Polishing his throat with sunflower seeds,' someone joked. 'Nonsense, it's polished with something else,' another voice interrupted, followed by a loud snap on the throat...'” The rumor of Chaliapin's arrival quickly spread throughout the town, and a huge crowd followed him. They asked him to sing, but he, smiling, refused and, still tossing sunflower seeds into his mouth, joked, “The throat is not polished...”